Repair or replace?

Repair or replace: an honest answer for your phone, laptop or console

A cracked screen, a swollen battery, a laptop that will not charge. The repairer says one price, the shop says another, and nobody tells you which is the smart money. Put in the repair quote, the age and what a replacement really costs, and get a verdict with the reasons, in plain English.

From when it was bought new, even if you bought it used.

Get two quotes. Verified repairers in the community give honest ones.

New or UK used, the one you would really buy today. Check the price index.

Find a verified repairerReplacement pricesSell it for parts

How the verdict is made

Three questions decide it

How much of a replacement is the repair? Under a quarter is usually an easy yes. Over half is usually a no, because you are paying new-phone money for an old phone. How old is it, and does it still get updates? A two-year-old phone with a new battery can serve you for three more years; a five-year-old laptop will find a new fault soon. What kind of fault is it? Screens, batteries, ports and cameras are routine. Motherboard and water-damage repairs fail far more often, so they only make sense with a written warranty.

Whatever the verdict, get two quotes. Verified repairers in our community give honest ones, and the price index tells you what a replacement really costs today.

Before you hand it over for repair

  • Back up your photos and chats, then sign out of accounts if you can
  • Agree the part grade: original, high-grade copy, or refurbished
  • Get the price, the warranty and the collection date in writing, even on WhatsApp
  • Photograph the phone and note the IMEI before you leave it
  • Pay the balance after testing it in the shop

Not worth fixing? Sell it for parts in the gadget market.

Questions people ask

Repair questions, answered

Is it worth repairing a cracked phone screen?

Usually yes when the quote is under a third of what a replacement would cost and the phone is under three years old. Insist on an original or high-grade screen; a cheap copy loses True Tone, brightness and touch accuracy.

Should I replace the battery or buy a new phone?

A battery is the cheapest repair that makes a phone feel new again. If the battery is the only problem and the phone still gets software updates, replace the battery.

When is a repair not worth it?

When the quote is more than half the replacement price, when the fault is on the motherboard or from water (those repairs often come back), when the gadget no longer gets updates, or when it has already been repaired twice.

Why are motherboard and water-damage repairs risky?

Corrosion keeps spreading after a water repair, and board-level work can fail weeks later. If you do repair, use a repairer who gives a written warranty and pay only after the phone has run for a few days.

Can I sell a faulty phone?

Yes. Repairers buy faulty phones for parts. List it honestly as "faulty or for parts" in the gadget market and let the quotes come to you.

All free gadget tools